Jason Ornduff has contributed to the November issue of the Illinois Institute of Continuing Legal Education’s Flashpoints Series, released monthly on its website. Flashpoints is the Institute's monthly e-newsletter that shares the latest legal updates and discusses trending topics across popular practice areas.
Jason's Flashpoints section comes from his chapter, "Estate Tax Elections and Strategies" in the IICLE Postmortem Estate Planning Handbook.
***
Most wills and trusts specifically allow the fiduciary a reasonable fee for the person’s efforts. In fact, even if the named fiduciary has already stated that the fiduciary will not be taking a fee, the instrument should still provide for it. If a corporate fiduciary must act at some point, it will do so only if fees can be paid for its services. Also, there are occasions in which a fee should be taken by even an individual fiduciary who is also the sole residuary beneficiary.
Whether Fees Should Be Taken
A common issue that arises at the initial meeting with the fiduciary is the question of fees. If the fiduciary is a bank or trust company, the issue of fees is quite simple. The corporate fiduciary will charge an administration fee based on the total size of the estate according to a published fee schedule. When a family member is the executor or trustee, however, often the person is willing to serve without taking an executor’s or trustee’s fee. In some cases, the beneficiaries who are also family members would expect the person to serve without a fee. Is this the right conclusion?
Fees can be a very sensitive matter when an individual is the fiduciary. One child taking a fee could be seen as getting more than the other children, who may not see the work their sibling is doing as anything other than an honor or a gratuitous family obligation. In response to the one person taking a fee, other family members could become more demanding of the person, always justifying their demands on the basis that the person is getting paid for the trouble. On the other hand, if the estate requires a tremendous amount of work, including gathering assets from many places, selling real estate, business interests, and the like, or simply going through the decedent’s lifetime accumulation of personal property, the task of the executor or trustee can be very time consuming. Less understood by the layperson but even more important is the fact that the individual fiduciary is taking on a tremendous personal liability, one that could come back to haunt the person if there is fighting among beneficiaries or family members.
In short, when discussing the question of fees, first and foremost, the family dynamic should be considered, and the question of fees should be discussed at the beginning. One way to handle the topic of fees is to have a private discussion with the fiduciary about fees and then discuss the matter with the rest of the residuary beneficiaries in a meeting. Many times, a fee should be waived even if, as is usually the case, the testamentary instrument provides for a fee. If the fiduciary is also the only residuary beneficiary (e.g., the surviving spouse, an only child), taking a fee is essentially paying oneself. Furthermore, a fiduciary fee is taxable ordinary income to the person. Therefore, a residuary beneficiary taking a fee is converting an inheritance, not subject to income tax, to taxable income. That does not make good sense.
For the estate that is subject to estate tax, fees allow for a planning opportunity. However, with changes in the federal income tax brackets, the value of this planning is diminished for most taxpayers. Fiduciary fees are deductible for estate tax purposes on Schedule J of IRS Form 706, United States Estate (and Generation-Skipping Transfer) Tax Return, www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f706.pdf. The top federal estate tax rate is 40 percent, and the top federal income tax rate is 37 percent. That is not much of a difference, but most fiduciaries may not be in the top bracket, so taking a fee can provide a small tax savings.
For example, assume that the trustee (single individual) of a taxable estate is also the only child and the sole residuary beneficiary. She has adjusted gross income (AGI) of about $110,000 a year and normally just hits the 24-percent bracket, paying $18,998 in federal income tax. She takes a fee of $100,000, for total 2026 AGI of $210,000, which pushes her into the 32-percent bracket. The estate tax savings is $40,000, and she personally pays an additional federal income tax of $24,661 (total tax of $43,656 based on the 2026 rates and tax brackets), resulting in an overall tax savings of $15,339 ($40,000 – $24,661). This is a simple example, though, as the income tax is never quite as cut and dried as that. The phase-out and limitations on itemized deductions and the fiduciary’s income from other sources will have an effect on the overall tax savings. Therefore, a good way to handle this situation is to coordinate with the fiduciary’s tax preparer and perhaps even run calculations using tax software to determine the likely tax savings of taking a fee. Still, given the top marginal rates, in almost all cases, taking a fiduciary fee for a taxable estate yields an overall tax savings.
Note also that the IRS has taken the position that fiduciary fees received by a nonprofessional fiduciary are subject to the self-employment tax. Rev.Rul. 58-5, 1958-1 Cum.Bull. 322.
If a fee is to be taken, it must be reasonable. There are no clear-cut guidelines on what constitutes a reasonable fee. Some will want to use an hourly rate, but what constitutes a good hourly rate and how such a rate is justified for the inexperienced fiduciary can be called into question. A more common and probably better choice is to base the fee on the size of the estate, with the fee schedules used by corporate fiduciaries as a guide. Generally, the IRS will not question a deduction for a fee that is based on these schedules because, if a corporate fiduciary were acting, the size of the fee would have been crafted in the competitive marketplace.
When Fees Should Be Taken
There is no specific rule as to when a fee or a partial fee should be taken. For smaller estates, fees are generally taken at the end of administration. Another way to handle fees is to pay on an interim basis (for example, every quarter) or after an event in the administration, such as the closing on the sale of the personal residence or filing an interim accounting. If there is a concern that beneficiaries might dispute the fee, it is best to get their consent before taking the fee, and in extreme cases, the fiduciary can petition the court for a ruling that the fee is reasonable and justified.
For the individual fiduciary of larger estates or estates that will take several years to complete, the timing of fees depends on two things. If the other beneficiaries might object to the fee, the timing issues in the preceding paragraph still come into play. If, however, there is no probable objection to the fee, the timing of the fee should be coordinated with the person’s tax preparer to yield the best tax result. For example, if the person is on the eve of retirement, deferring part of the fee until the following year might make the most sense. On the other hand, if the person is anticipating a promotion at work and a raise in the following year, taking some of the fee early might make the most sense tax wise. Finally, if the estate is large enough, it almost never makes sense to take the entire fee at the end of administration. Instead, the fee should be stretched out over a period of years.
***
November 2026 IICLE FLASHPOINTS | IICLE
*Originally published on iicle.com*
***
About Jason Ornduff
Jason advises high-net-worth families, business owners, executives, professionals, and celebrities on state and federal laws regarding wealth transfer to the next generation, including estate planning, estate and trust administration, and estate and gift tax issues. Jason also counsels closely held companies on various legal issues, especially in the areas of succession planning.
Jason is a past president of the Greater North Shore Estate and Financial Planning Council. He is also a Fellow in the American College of Trust and Estate Counsel (ACTEC), serves on the Illinois Institute of Continuing Legal Education’s Estate Planning Short Course planning board, and is a member of the Chicago Estate Planning Council.
Illinois Institute of Continuing Legal Education
IICLE® is a 501(c)(3) not-for-profit organization that accomplishes its mission through (1) the presentation of continuing legal education programs designed by and for Illinois attorneys; (2) the publication of comprehensive practice handbooks and forms authored by and for Illinois attorneys; and (3) the continued development and maintenance of additional legal resources designed to enhance Illinois law practice.
Harrison LLP
Harrison LLP is a national law firm that assists clients in defining and achieving their private wealth goals, delivering peace of mind through sophisticated and practical legal counsel. Founded in 2003, the firm advises fiduciaries, high net worth families, and family offices on estate planning, trust administration, charitable guidance, tax controversies, trust and estate litigation, succession planning, and family law.